
Rhys Chatham’s Essentialist @ CEC 9/8/2006
It was actually a little quaint. And Mr. Smith overdetermines the influence of Southern Lord on Chatham’s set; running through a few rehashed Slayer and Black Album-era Metallica riffs is neither avant-garde nor metal. No. It’s “high culture” slumming as “low culture”, which is both pedantic and patronizing. As John Darnielle put it in Decibel’s now infamous hipster metal roundtable:
They start listening to a little metal, but they sort of want to describe the metal in terms that makes it part of their shtick instead of its own universe. Their mode is sort of the gateway drug to that. It seems a little intellectual sometimes.
Additionally, this. And, while I’m at it, this. Oh, the guilt! Is it impossible to judge metal on its own merits, “artful” or otherwise, rather than falsely elevate it in the name of good taste? Sure, it’s a cheap polemic and the easiest way to approach extreme music in a specious manner, but it does such a disservice to artists who don’t find themselves adorning the pages of The Times, The New Yorker and Artforum before being accorded the respectability they deserve as artists in and of themselves.
That sort of criticism is better left to cagey A&R personnel and twitchy PR attachés, hired to devise marketing strategies for crossover appeal, etc.