It rules.
MLB 2K10 is a vast improvement over the last version of the game I purchased two years ago. The reasons are simple. It’s taken the same approach that Madden took in sharpening his namesake video game: made it harder and more realistic. The approach at the plate no longer requires the hack and slash tactics in ’08; you can actually look at pitches and maybe even draw a walk. I’ve drawn exactly one walk to date, with Ben Francisco as DH no less! The discipline required to have good at-bats is a dramatic change from ‘08’s comical home run derby, where having consecutive multiple home run games with Pedro Feliz or Geoff Jenkins wasn’t out of the question.
The pitching controls? Meh. I don’t see the big diff. This is part of the problem with marketing sports games today. At this point, everyone knows that the real differences from year to year are few. How do you generate excitement about a game whose main improvement is that the rosters are updated? Even the venerable Madden franchise has suffered a decline in sales!
Other points:
- I love the MLB Today feature, but wish it would replace the franchise mode altogether. Why not merge the two experiences?
- I hate unlocking things. Why not emulate those classic Madden games and just include the classic teams (or simulacra thereof) and stadiums in the game? If you’re a fan of sports games, these sorts of loyalty gimmicks don’t really work out. I want to play as the Phillies (or hell, the A’s) in all of the parks they ever played in, in my choice of uniforms. Can I get an amen from the guys at Uni Watch?
- The art of stealing bases became more difficult in the new game. It’s a lot to try to manage an at-bat while simultaneously pulling the trigger (literally) to steal second. It’d be different if you were playing as the first or third base coach, but you’re not.
Apart from those details, I love every minute of the game. Last night I pulled off a thrilling 10 inning comeback win over the lowly Pirates. The game ended on a walkoff homer by Ryan Howard, the team gathering around home as he plated the winning run. It was amazing. MLB 2K10 is a huge improvement over previous efforts and I look forward to playing the 2010 campaign with the Fightin’ Phils.