I was one of the first people to write about this — Â you can read my rather impolitic tweet here — and I hope I’m one of the last. I like what Tom had to say today over at P’unk Ave’s blog, but I’d like to take this a step further and talk for just a second about what it means for the Philly blogging community, inasmuch as one exists.
Y’all look really dumb. Anyone who vented spleen about the so-called “blogger tax” Monday morning really lived up to the blogger stereotype, which essentially boils down to reactionary twits who can’t so much as fact check before completely going bonkers.
Worse, it shows that for all the gains blogging has made in becoming mainstream media, most bloggers have zero news sense. I don’t work at the New York Times, but in the three years I’ve spent at comcast.net I’ve learned a ton from folks who are trained journalists about what is news and what isn’t.
Y’all got played. The news cycle is dead. If it weren’t for Elin splitting with Tiger, there’d be just about no news at all. (Little secret: people are pretty tired of the whole Lohan saga by now.) If you’re a small news org looking to make hay in late August, go with something local and definitely do something that screams link bait.
It worked. That story spread like wildfire simply because all the self-professed media firemen ran around spraying gasoline. I’m not very active in the local blogging community, but I’d be hard-pressed to join forces with people who spazzed out so relentlessly over something that’s been a known issue for quite some time.
Worse, there were a handful of people who felt that blogging should be subsidized. I’m all for government subsidies, particularly those that go toward housing and feeding people, promoting general welfare sort of stuff. Blogging? You must be kidding. Unless you’re talking about folks electing to pay donations to help cover hosting fees or what have you, you must seriously be joking. Isn’t this what student loans are for?
People really need to ask themselves who’s hurt by this. I’m guessing that most bloggers won’t have the taxman banging down their door anytime soon, or Mayor Nutter holding a press conference outside your apartment building to talk about how much you owe the city in back taxes. Call it a hunch, but I’m guessing most people don’t even have Google ads enabled on their sites. Funnier still, isn’t blogging a dying trend? Isn’t it funny how this story spread virally on Twitter and not throughout the blogosphere as it might’ve just a few years ago.
I get that $300 seems like a chunk of change to folks who are freelancing. I’ve been there. It’s a mess. The hassle made me ditch freelancing entirely and I was fortunate enough to find gainful employment. But if $300 seems like too much to start a business, you have to question your commitment to making it work, as well as possibly rehashing your business model. Fact of the matter is, people want to abolish the small business tax as a lever against all sorts of other parts of the Philadelphia tax code no doubt. Could you imagine what it would be like here if people were paying less in taxes? They’d have to shut the city down and turn out the lights! Next time you complain about the business privilege tax or city wage even, talk to your friends in the ‘burbs who are paying through the nose on property taxes, not to mention their utilities.
When I wrote that tweet about bloggers owing the same $300 bucks as someone baking cupcakes, I forgot to add that at least cupcakes provide a social good, not to mention that they’re freakin’ delicious. Blogging can be a lot of fun, but you really can’t take yourself too seriously. Try harder next time, guys. You’re better than this. It makes us all look bad when you don’t.
Elsewhere, Sean Blanda tries to set the record straight.